{- | "Injectivity", or more precisely, "constructor headedness", is a property of functions defined by pattern matching that helps us solve constraints involving blocked applications of such functions. "Blocked" shall mean here that pattern matching is blocked on a meta variable, and constructor headedness lets us learn more about that meta variable. Consider the simple example: @ isZero : Nat -> Bool isZero zero = true isZero (suc n) = false @ This function is constructor-headed, meaning that all rhss are headed by a distinct constructor. Thus, on a constraint like @ isZero ?X = false : Bool @ involving an application of @isZero@ that is blocked on meta variable @?X@, we can exploit injectivity and learn that @?X = suc ?Y@ for a new meta-variable @?Y@. Which functions qualify for injectivity? 1. The function needs to have at least one non-absurd clause that has a proper match, meaning that the function can actually be blocked on a meta. Proper matches are these patterns: - data constructor (@ConP@, but not record constructor) - literal (@LitP@) - HIT-patterns (@DefP@) Projection patterns (@ProjP@) are excluded because metas cannot occupy their place! 2. All the clauses that satisfy (1.) need to be headed by a distinct constructor. -} module Agda.TypeChecking.Injectivity where import Control.Applicative import Control.Monad.Except import Control.Monad.Fail import Control.Monad.State import Control.Monad.Reader import Control.Monad.Trans.Maybe import qualified Data.Map as Map import qualified Data.Set as Set import Data.Maybe import Data.Traversable hiding (for) import Data.Semigroup ((<>)) import qualified Agda.Syntax.Abstract.Name as A import Agda.Syntax.Common import Agda.Syntax.Internal import Agda.Syntax.Internal.Pattern import Agda.TypeChecking.Irrelevance (isIrrelevantOrPropM) import Agda.TypeChecking.Monad import Agda.TypeChecking.Substitute import Agda.TypeChecking.Reduce import {-# SOURCE #-} Agda.TypeChecking.MetaVars import {-# SOURCE #-} Agda.TypeChecking.Conversion import Agda.TypeChecking.Pretty import Agda.TypeChecking.Polarity import Agda.TypeChecking.Warnings import Agda.Utils.Either import Agda.Utils.Functor import Agda.Utils.List import Agda.Utils.Maybe import Agda.Utils.Monad import Agda.Utils.Permutation import Agda.Utils.Pretty ( prettyShow ) import Agda.Utils.Impossible headSymbol :: Term -> TCM (Maybe TermHead) headSymbol v = do -- ignoreAbstractMode $ do -- Andreas, 2013-02-18 ignoreAbstractMode leads to information leakage v <- constructorForm =<< ignoreBlocking <$> reduceHead v case v of Def f _ -> do let yes = return $ Just $ ConsHead f no = return $ Nothing def <- theDef <$> do ignoreAbstractMode $ getConstInfo f -- Andreas, 2013-02-18 -- if we do not ignoreAbstractMode here, abstract Functions get turned -- into Axioms, but we want to distinguish these. case def of Datatype{} -> yes Record{} -> yes DataOrRecSig{} -> yes Axiom{} -> do reportSLn "tc.inj.axiom" 50 $ "headSymbol: " ++ prettyShow f ++ " is an Axiom." -- Don't treat axioms in the current mutual block -- as constructors (they might have definitions we -- don't know about yet). caseMaybeM (asksTC envMutualBlock) yes $ \ mb -> do fs <- mutualNames <$> lookupMutualBlock mb if Set.member f fs then no else yes Function{} -> no Primitive{} -> no PrimitiveSort{} -> no GeneralizableVar{} -> __IMPOSSIBLE__ Constructor{} -> __IMPOSSIBLE__ AbstractDefn{}-> __IMPOSSIBLE__ -- Andreas, 2019-07-10, issue #3900: canonicalName needs ignoreAbstractMode Con c _ _ -> ignoreAbstractMode $ Just . ConsHead <$> canonicalName (conName c) Sort _ -> return (Just SortHead) Pi _ _ -> return (Just PiHead) Var i [] -> return (Just $ VarHead i) -- Only naked variables. Otherwise substituting a neutral term is not guaranteed to stay neutral. Lit _ -> return Nothing -- TODO: LitHead (for literals with no constructorForm) Lam{} -> return Nothing Var{} -> return Nothing Level{} -> return Nothing MetaV{} -> return Nothing DontCare{} -> return Nothing Dummy s _ -> __IMPOSSIBLE_VERBOSE__ s -- | Do a full whnf and treat neutral terms as rigid. Used on the arguments to -- an injective functions and to the right-hand side. headSymbol' :: (PureTCM m, MonadError TCErr m) => Term -> m (Maybe TermHead) headSymbol' v = do v <- traverse constructorForm =<< reduceB v case v of Blocked{} -> return Nothing NotBlocked _ v -> case v of Def g _ -> return $ Just $ ConsHead g Con c _ _ -> return $ Just $ ConsHead $ conName c Var i _ -> return $ Just (VarHead i) Sort _ -> return $ Just SortHead Pi _ _ -> return $ Just PiHead Lit _ -> return Nothing Lam{} -> return Nothing Level{} -> return Nothing DontCare{} -> return Nothing MetaV{} -> __IMPOSSIBLE__ Dummy s _ -> __IMPOSSIBLE_VERBOSE__ s -- | Does deBruijn variable i correspond to a top-level argument, and if so -- which one (index from the left). topLevelArg :: Clause -> Int -> Maybe TermHead topLevelArg Clause{ namedClausePats = ps } i = case [ n | (n, VarP _ (DBPatVar _ j)) <- zip [0..] $ map namedArg ps, i == j ] of [] -> Nothing [n] -> Just (VarHead n) _:_:_ -> __IMPOSSIBLE__ -- | Join a list of inversion maps. joinHeadMaps :: [InversionMap c] -> InversionMap c joinHeadMaps = Map.unionsWith (<>) -- | Update the heads of an inversion map. updateHeads :: Monad m => (TermHead -> [c] -> m TermHead) -> InversionMap c -> m (InversionMap c) updateHeads f m = joinHeadMaps <$> mapM f' (Map.toList m) where f' (h, c) = (`Map.singleton` c) <$> f h c checkInjectivity :: QName -> [Clause] -> TCM FunctionInverse checkInjectivity f cs0 | not (any properlyMatchingClause cs) = do reportSLn "tc.inj.check.pointless" 35 $ "Injectivity of " ++ prettyShow (A.qnameToConcrete f) ++ " would be pointless." return NotInjective | otherwise = checkInjectivity' f cs where -- We can filter out absurd clauses. cs = filter (isJust . clauseBody) cs0 -- We cannot filter out clauses that have no proper match, because -- these could be catch-all clauses. -- However, we need at least one proper match to get injectivity started. properlyMatchingClause = any (properlyMatching' False False . namedArg) . namedClausePats -- | Precondition: all the given clauses are non-absurd and contain a proper match. checkInjectivity' :: QName -> [Clause] -> TCM FunctionInverse checkInjectivity' f cs = fromMaybe NotInjective <.> runMaybeT $ do reportSLn "tc.inj.check" 40 $ "Checking injectivity of " ++ prettyShow f let varToArg :: Clause -> TermHead -> MaybeT TCM TermHead varToArg c (VarHead i) = MaybeT $ return $ topLevelArg c i varToArg _ h = return h -- We don't need to consider absurd clauses let computeHead c@Clause{ clauseBody = Just body , clauseType = Just tbody } = do maybeIrr <- fromRight (const True) <.> runBlocked $ isIrrelevantOrPropM tbody h <- if maybeIrr then return UnknownHead else varToArg c =<< do lift $ fromMaybe UnknownHead <$> do addContext (clauseTel c) $ headSymbol body return [Map.singleton h [c]] computeHead _ = return [] hdMap <- joinHeadMaps . concat <$> mapM computeHead cs case Map.lookup UnknownHead hdMap of Just (_:_:_) -> empty -- More than one unknown head: we can't really do anything in that case. _ -> return () reportSLn "tc.inj.check" 20 $ prettyShow f ++ " is potentially injective." reportSDoc "tc.inj.check" 30 $ nest 2 $ vcat $ for (Map.toList hdMap) $ \ (h, uc) -> text (prettyShow h) <+> "-->" <+> case uc of [c] -> prettyTCM $ map namedArg $ namedClausePats c _ -> "(multiple clauses)" return $ Inverse hdMap -- | If a clause is over-applied we can't trust the head (Issue 2944). For -- instance, the clause might be `f ps = u , v` and the actual call `f vs -- .fst`. In this case the head will be the head of `u` rather than `_,_`. checkOverapplication :: forall m. (HasConstInfo m) => Elims -> InversionMap Clause -> m (InversionMap Clause) checkOverapplication es = updateHeads overapplied where overapplied :: TermHead -> [Clause] -> m TermHead overapplied h cs | all (not . isOverapplied) cs = return h overapplied h cs = ifM (isSuperRigid h) (return h) (return UnknownHead) -- A super-rigid head is one that can't be eliminated. Crucially, this is -- applied after instantiateVars, so VarHeads are really bound variables. isSuperRigid SortHead = return True isSuperRigid PiHead = return True isSuperRigid VarHead{} = return True isSuperRigid UnknownHead = return True -- or False, doesn't matter isSuperRigid (ConsHead q) = do def <- getConstInfo q return $ case theDef def of Axiom{} -> True DataOrRecSig{} -> True AbstractDefn{} -> True Function{} -> False Datatype{} -> True Record{} -> True Constructor{conSrcCon = ConHead{ conDataRecord = d, conFields = fs }} -> d == IsData || null fs -- Record constructors can be eliminated by projections Primitive{} -> False PrimitiveSort{} -> __IMPOSSIBLE__ GeneralizableVar{} -> __IMPOSSIBLE__ isOverapplied Clause{ namedClausePats = ps } = length es > length ps -- | Turn variable heads, referring to top-level argument positions, into -- proper heads. These might still be `VarHead`, but in that case they refer to -- deBruijn variables. Checks that the instantiated heads are still rigid and -- distinct. instantiateVarHeads :: forall m c. (PureTCM m, MonadError TCErr m) => QName -> Elims -> InversionMap c -> m (Maybe (InversionMap c)) instantiateVarHeads f es m = runMaybeT $ updateHeads (const . instHead) m where instHead :: TermHead -> MaybeT m TermHead instHead h@(VarHead i) | Just (Apply arg) <- es !!! i = MaybeT $ headSymbol' (unArg arg) | otherwise = empty -- impossible? instHead h = return h -- | Argument should be in weak head normal form. functionInverse :: (PureTCM m, MonadError TCErr m) => Term -> m InvView functionInverse = \case Def f es -> do inv <- defInverse <$> getConstInfo f case inv of NotInjective -> return NoInv Inverse m -> maybe NoInv (Inv f es) <$> (traverse (checkOverapplication es) =<< instantiateVarHeads f es m) -- NB: Invertible functions are never classified as -- projection-like, so this is fine, we are not -- missing parameters. (Andreas, 2013-11-01) _ -> return NoInv data InvView = Inv QName [Elim] (InversionMap Clause) | NoInv -- | Precondition: The first term must be blocked on the given meta and the second must be neutral. useInjectivity :: MonadConversion m => CompareDirection -> Blocker -> CompareAs -> Term -> Term -> m () useInjectivity dir blocker ty blk neu = locallyTC eInjectivityDepth succ $ do inv <- functionInverse blk -- Injectivity might cause non-termination for unsatisfiable constraints -- (#431, #3067). Look at the number of active problems and the injectivity -- depth to detect this. nProblems <- Set.size <$> viewTC eActiveProblems injDepth <- viewTC eInjectivityDepth let depth = max nProblems injDepth maxDepth <- maxInversionDepth case inv of NoInv -> fallback -- not invertible Inv f blkArgs hdMap | depth > maxDepth -> warning (InversionDepthReached f) >> fallback | otherwise -> do reportSDoc "tc.inj.use" 30 $ fsep $ pwords "useInjectivity on" ++ [ prettyTCM blk, prettyTCM cmp, prettyTCM neu, prettyTCM ty] let canReduceToSelf = Map.member (ConsHead f) hdMap || Map.member UnknownHead hdMap case neu of -- f us == f vs <=> us == vs -- Crucially, this relies on `f vs` being neutral and only works -- if `f` is not a possible head for `f us`. Def f' neuArgs | f == f', not canReduceToSelf -> do fTy <- defType <$> getConstInfo f reportSDoc "tc.inj.use" 20 $ vcat [ fsep (pwords "comparing application of injective function" ++ [prettyTCM f] ++ pwords "at") , nest 2 $ fsep $ punctuate comma $ map prettyTCM blkArgs , nest 2 $ fsep $ punctuate comma $ map prettyTCM neuArgs , nest 2 $ "and type" <+> prettyTCM fTy ] fs <- getForcedArgs f pol <- getPolarity' cmp f reportSDoc "tc.inj.invert.success" 20 $ hsep ["Successful spine comparison of", prettyTCM f] app (compareElims pol fs fTy (Def f [])) blkArgs neuArgs -- f us == c vs -- Find the clause unique clause `f ps` with head `c` and unify -- us == ps with fresh metas for the pattern variables of ps. -- If there's no such clause we can safely throw an error. _ -> headSymbol' neu >>= \ case Nothing -> do reportSDoc "tc.inj.use" 20 $ fsep $ pwords "no head symbol found for" ++ [prettyTCM neu] ++ pwords ", so not inverting" fallback Just (ConsHead f') | f == f', canReduceToSelf -> do reportSDoc "tc.inj.use" 20 $ fsep $ pwords "head symbol" ++ [prettyTCM f'] ++ pwords "can reduce to self, so not inverting" fallback -- We can't invert in this case, since we can't -- tell the difference between a solution that makes -- the blocked term neutral and one that makes progress. Just hd -> invertFunction cmp blk inv hd fallback err success where err = typeError $ app (\ u v -> UnequalTerms cmp u v ty) blk neu where fallback = addConstraint blocker $ app (ValueCmp cmp ty) blk neu success blk' = app (compareAs cmp ty) blk' neu cmpApp :: (Comparison, (a -> a -> b) -> a -> a -> b) cmpApp = case dir of DirEq -> (CmpEq, id) DirLeq -> (CmpLeq, id) DirGeq -> (CmpLeq, flip) (cmp, app) = cmpApp -- | The second argument should be a blocked application and the third argument -- the inverse of the applied function. invertFunction :: MonadConversion m => Comparison -> Term -> InvView -> TermHead -> m () -> m () -> (Term -> m ()) -> m () invertFunction _ _ NoInv _ fallback _ _ = fallback invertFunction cmp blk (Inv f blkArgs hdMap) hd fallback err success = do fTy <- defType <$> getConstInfo f reportSDoc "tc.inj.use" 20 $ vcat [ "inverting injective function" hsep [prettyTCM f, ":", prettyTCM fTy] , "for" pretty hd , nest 2 $ "args =" <+> prettyList (map prettyTCM blkArgs) ] -- Clauses with unknown heads are also possible candidates case fromMaybe [] $ Map.lookup hd hdMap <> Map.lookup UnknownHead hdMap of [] -> err _:_:_ -> fallback [cl@Clause{ clauseTel = tel }] -> speculateMetas fallback $ do let ps = clausePats cl perm = fromMaybe __IMPOSSIBLE__ $ clausePerm cl -- These are what dot patterns should be instantiated at ms <- map unArg <$> newTelMeta tel reportSDoc "tc.inj.invert" 20 $ vcat [ "meta patterns" <+> prettyList (map prettyTCM ms) , " perm =" <+> text (show perm) , " tel =" <+> prettyTCM tel , " ps =" <+> prettyList (map (text . show) ps) ] -- and this is the order the variables occur in the patterns let msAux = permute (invertP __IMPOSSIBLE__ $ compactP perm) ms let sub = parallelS (reverse ms) margs <- runReaderT (evalStateT (mapM metaElim ps) msAux) sub reportSDoc "tc.inj.invert" 20 $ vcat [ "inversion" , nest 2 $ vcat [ "lhs =" <+> prettyTCM margs , "rhs =" <+> prettyTCM blkArgs , "type =" <+> prettyTCM fTy ] ] -- Since we do not care for the value of non-variant metas here, -- we can treat 'Nonvariant' as 'Invariant'. -- That ensures these metas do not remain unsolved. pol <- purgeNonvariant <$> getPolarity' cmp f fs <- getForcedArgs f -- The clause might not give as many patterns as there -- are arguments (point-free style definitions). let blkArgs' = take (length margs) blkArgs compareElims pol fs fTy (Def f []) margs blkArgs' -- Check that we made progress. r <- liftReduce $ unfoldDefinitionStep False (Def f []) f blkArgs case r of YesReduction _ blk' -> do reportSDoc "tc.inj.invert.success" 20 $ hsep ["Successful inversion of", prettyTCM f, "at", pretty hd] KeepMetas <$ success blk' NoReduction{} -> do reportSDoc "tc.inj.invert" 30 $ vcat [ "aborting inversion;" <+> prettyTCM blk , "does not reduce" ] return RollBackMetas where nextMeta :: (MonadState [Term] m, MonadFail m) => m Term nextMeta = do m : ms <- get put ms return m dotP :: MonadReader Substitution m => Term -> m Term dotP v = do sub <- ask return $ applySubst sub v metaElim :: (MonadState [Term] m, MonadReader Substitution m, HasConstInfo m, MonadFail m) => Arg DeBruijnPattern -> m Elim metaElim (Arg _ (ProjP o p)) = Proj o <$> getOriginalProjection p metaElim (Arg info p) = Apply . Arg info <$> metaPat p metaArgs :: (MonadState [Term] m, MonadReader Substitution m, MonadFail m) => [NamedArg DeBruijnPattern] -> m Args metaArgs args = mapM (traverse $ metaPat . namedThing) args metaPat :: (MonadState [Term] m, MonadReader Substitution m, MonadFail m) => DeBruijnPattern -> m Term metaPat (DotP _ v) = dotP v metaPat (VarP _ _) = nextMeta metaPat (IApplyP{}) = nextMeta metaPat (ConP c mt args) = Con c (fromConPatternInfo mt) . map Apply <$> metaArgs args metaPat (DefP o q args) = Def q . map Apply <$> metaArgs args metaPat (LitP _ l) = return $ Lit l metaPat ProjP{} = __IMPOSSIBLE__ forcePiUsingInjectivity :: Type -> TCM Type forcePiUsingInjectivity t = reduceB t >>= \ case Blocked _ blkTy -> do let blk = unEl blkTy inv <- functionInverse blk blkTy <$ invertFunction CmpEq blk inv PiHead fallback err success NotBlocked _ t -> return t where fallback = return () err = typeError (ShouldBePi t) success _ = return ()